Smoke & Slow

Which Smoker Should a Beginner Buy?

Electric, pellet or charcoal — start here. Plain-English roundups that give you one safe default pick per type, with a live price you can act on.

If you’re buying your first smoker, the choice comes down to one question, and it isn’t about brand or price: how hands-on do you want to be?That single decision points you at one of three types, and everything else — budget, size, flavor — follows from it.

Electric smokersare the least intimidating. You plug them in, set a temperature on a dial or digital panel, and the smoker holds it for you — no fire to manage. If the idea of babysitting coals makes you nervous, start here. The trade-off is a milder smoke flavor than charcoal. Pellet smokers(pellet grills) are almost as easy: a hopper of wood pellets feeds an auger, a controller holds your set temperature, and you get real wood smoke with very little effort — the popular “set it and forget it” option, at a higher price. Charcoal smokers give the truest barbecue flavor and cost the least up front, but you manage a live fire and learn to control temperature with air vents. More reward, more of a learning curve.

For most nervous first-timers we’d point you at an electric smoker or a pellet smoker: both let you focus on the food instead of the fire while you learn. If you specifically want that classic charcoal-and-wood taste and don’t mind tending a fire, a charcoal smoker like the cult-favorite Weber Smokey Mountain is the way in — or the Pit Barrel Cooker, which burns charcoal with one fixed vent and nothing to adjust. If you would rather have one cooker that smokes low and then sears steaks, read our Char-Griller AKORN review — an insulated steel kamado with a published 200–700°F range. Not sure yet? Our best smokers for beginners roundup lines up the top pick from every type side by side.

The mistakes beginners make when buying a smoker

The biggest one is buying too much smoker.A giant offset “stick burner” looks the part, but it’s the hardest kind to run and burns through wood fast — a frustrating first smoker. Start with something forgiving and upgrade later if the hobby sticks. If an offset is exactly what you want anyway, our Oklahoma Joe’s Laredo 1100 review is the honest version of what one asks of you. The second mistake is skipping the thermometer. No smoker, however expensive, tells you when the meat inside is done; a good meat thermometer is the accessory that actually determines whether your first cook succeeds. The third is chasing features you won’t use— WiFi, apps, searing grates — instead of the two things that matter for a beginner: does it hold a steady low temperature, and is it big enough for what you want to cook?

What decides the price

Smoker prices are driven mostly by fuel type and automation. Budget analog electric and simple charcoal smokers start low; pellet grills cost more because you’re paying for the auger, controller and hopper that do the work for you. Bigger cooking area and heavier, better-insulated steel add cost too — and insulation genuinely matters if you’ll smoke in cold weather. You do notneed to spend a lot to smoke well: some of our favorite beginner picks are among the cheapest. Prices on every page here are pulled live from Amazon and dated, so you always see the current number, never a stale one. If you have a budget in mind, start at the right rung — under $300, under $500 or under $1,000, which is where every type of smoker becomes affordable and where it is easiest to overspend. If you are shopping in November, our Black Friday & Cyber Monday deals hub covers which smoker types have historically discounted and which rarely do; and if the smoker is a present for someone else, read buying someone their first smoker first.

Once you have narrowed it to a type, the model reviews are where the decision actually gets made. If pellets are your answer, the brand almost everyone names first is Traeger — our Traeger Pro 780 review works through what the premium really buys against a pellet grill costing half as much, and why we would only recommend it on a discount. On charcoal, the choice usually comes down to two cookers, and we have put them head to head: Pit Barrel Cooker vs Weber Smokey Mountain is really a question about whether you want to be allowed to adjust the fire at all, and AKORN vs Weber kettle settles whether an insulated kamado is worth twice the price of the cheapest serious charcoal grill. If you would rather charcoal behaved like an oven, the Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600 review covers the cooker that puts a thermostat on a charcoal fire. And if you are shopping by badge rather than by fuel, Pit Boss vs Masterbuilt explains the thing that makes that comparison unusual: the two brands barely compete, because one is pellet-first and the other electric-first, and the only category with both names in it is the propane cabinet.

Two more pages answer the questions people ask at the cheap and the expensive ends of that shelf. At the cheap end, our Pit Boss 440 review looks at about the least a recognized brand charges for a pellet grill and lands on the one spec that decides whether it suits you — a five-pound hopper, which is two to five hours of cooking rather than an overnight. At the expensive end, AKORN vs Kamado Joe puts insulated steel against ceramic and finds that the cheaper cooker publishes the bigger primary grate — which turns the ceramic question into one about warranties and decades rather than about next Saturday.

If you already know what you want to cook, start there instead of with the fuel type, because three cuts have genuinely different answers. Chicken is decided by the top of a cooker’s range rather than the bottom — rubbery skin is a heat problem — so best smokers for chicken sorts on the published ceiling. Fish is the mirror image, and best smokers for fish sorts on how low each cooker will run. And best smokers for sausage is about hanging room and a gentle start, which no other page here ranks on.

Below, each guide gives you one clear top pick with a live price plus a short list of alternatives, all reasoned from the makers’ published specs and honest beginner-fit — not from lab testing we didn’t do. Here’s exactly how we pick.

Everything in Smokers

Elsewhere on Smoke & Slow